Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

is WALKERA heil good? or is trex better?

Collapse

Zenm Tech Pte Ltd

Collapse

Visit Zenmtech at rc.zenmtech.com

X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    is WALKERA heil good? or is trex better?

    if i was wonder is WALKERA heli better than trex 450xl? which WALKERA modle is about the same as trex 450xl?

    #2
    Please refer to this phrase :

    You pay peanuts, you get monkey.

    In chinese :

    yi fen qian, yi fen hou.

    Comment


      #3
      Trex-Trex-Trex

      Hi black_dice,

      Most season flyers I have met who have been on this hobby long enough to know the RC heli "in-side-out" would highly recommend the Trex 450XL.

      I personally think that Trex is a great way to fly.

      Originally posted by black_dice
      if i was wonder is WALKERA heli better than trex 450xl? which WALKERA modle is about the same as trex 450xl?
      Heli
      Honey Bee CP2 : Sold (Maiden:17 Dec 05)
      Trex 450XL (CDE) : MM450TH, Quark 33A, GY401, JR RS10DS (Maiden : Align Frame - 1 Jul 06; SuperFrame - 29 Aug 06)

      Plane
      Estarter : Align 450s, Align 25A, Electron 6 (Maiden :16 Sep 06)

      PT-17w : Sold
      Buggy
      Acme NB 16 : Half 8 Nitro (Maiden :23 Dec 06)


      Transmtter : JR PCM 9X II, Aggressor SRX
      Charger : Tahmazo T15
      Balancer : TP205
      Battery :Thunder Power, FullRiver, Warbird


      Comment


        #4
        i think good or bad will depend on how much $$$ you wanna set aside for this hobby..

        Comment


          #5
          It depends on how precise the heli interpret the inputs from the pilot. Smooth linkage movement, precise movement, amount of free play, etc....All these add to the cost of the mechanics put into the heli....I have seen Walkera performing tricks....If movements are not precise and pilot able to correct it, it makes it a good heli too....However, some movements depends on external devices, eg. Gyro.....A good Gyro holds the tail well......
          Chai

          Lets' moveon.......

          Comment


            #6
            Walkera heli are like those product assembled behind those backlane slog shop , if you are lucky , you get a jewel otherwise and most of the time you will get junk. The fact is that they are more concern about the quantity they produce per month. Well , if you are already an experience pilot , then you wont face problem , you can easily turn junk into a workable flying heli ... and that's where I am. Trex sold in unassembled form (not fair to compare to those rtf walkera) and also it does not come rtf with radio and other electric , therefore how good the heli end up will depend on your equipments you use , usually most pilot use the best money can effort. If you are just starting out , I advise you to get the walkera #4 (HB fp clone but 50% cheaper) to train your flying skill and heli repairing. Those #36 / 60 no doubt they are more stable due to the higher headspeed and mass they will cost more if you crash and they do have thier design flaw as well. And finally , it is only logical to compare Trex to those unassembled heli like aplus400 or SJM and etc.

            just my 2 cents
            Esky HBT
            Esky Lama V3
            Walkera #4 (honey bee fp clone)
            Walkera #22D (MS Hornet 2 clone)
            Walkera #35 (Zap400 clone)
            Walkera #36 (mix zap400 / trex clone)
            Walkera #60 (all metal airframe)
            Align Trex XL HDE
            MiniTitan E325
            ARK X-450

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by black_dice
              "is WALKERA heli better than trex 450xl?
              Boy ! ...I wonder whatever gave you that notion ?



              ......Not taking anything away from Walkera owners and flyers anywhere ! dun me !
              Seriously running out of ...Storage space !

              Comment


                #8
                For what its worth, the Walkera is great bang for the buck......cheap n not so bad/good. I have the Walkera 4 FP and its great fun while it worked. It came with simulator software (Truflight2.0) n cable so you can train abit on comp b4 trying for real. I got it online for abt SGD200 with delivery n extra battery.

                But spares is a problem and its quality is so so at best. But for a cheap intro, its hard to beat. The blades are tough and dont break easily.

                Having said all this, i have a Trex 450XL on order....... HAHAHAHHHHA

                Comment


                  #9
                  I got a Walkera 5-5 Baby lama ....forever changed my mind about Walkeras helis !

                  Haven't even fly the heli and the rotor blade's broken aredi !

                  Great choice on the 450XL
                  Seriously running out of ...Storage space !

                  Comment


                    #10
                    oh alright thanks for all

                    Comment


                      #11
                      my budget is about 700 what can i get?

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by black_dice
                        my budget is about 700 what can i get?
                        let me try:
                        optic 6 - $230
                        electron 6 - $70
                        crystals - $26
                        walkera 60 - $250??
                        the balance - $200 for battery and charger

                        Comment


                          #13
                          I think u can get an Optic 6 complete with servo...
                          And a T-rex kit..if u are lucky..
                          My Hangar:

                          Heli 1:T-REX 450SE (Hughes MD 500)
                          (SE-maiden 15/03/06)
                          (XL-maiden 16/10/05)

                          Heli 2:RAPTOR 50 TITAN
                          (TITAN-maiden 16/06/2006)

                          Heli 3:T-REX 500ESP (T-rex maiden 25/9/10)
                          (FLASHER 500-maiden 08/10/2009 R.I.P:09/08/10)

                          Heli 4:Flasher 250
                          (maiden 13/09/2010)

                          Airplane 1:GWS A-4SU Skyhawk For Sale
                          Airplane 2:GWS P-40N WarHawk RAAF maiden flight 20/08/10 For Sale

                          Transmitter:
                          JR 9XII(XPS 2.4)

                          Its all fun & games till the bills come..

                          Comment


                            #14
                            I flew walkera heli before and i can say it did flew well except that parts may not be available easily and you will end up using compatible parts which in the end will cost the same as getting a trex kits.

                            When i flew Trex XL, I felt it is more stable & easier to control then walkera heli. Jus my own opinion. I did saw someone flew walkera with no problem also.Further more, parts are available locally.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              You do not need to go for Electron 6. Some even encounter problem using Electron 6. My electron 6 fail on me before.

                              There are alternate model by Hitec that I feel better than Electron 6 and yet cheaper:

                              Hitec Dual Conv, 8Channels: HFD-08RO
                              S$ 62.20
                              http://shop.rotor.com.sg/show-detail.asp?prodid={6A69EC48-683B-4F96-941D-3949E3247FDE}

                              Hitec Single-Conv, 6Channels: HFS-06MT
                              S$ 47.40
                              http://shop.rotor.com.sg/show-detail.asp?prodid={EA10E5C2-6BAD-46A4-B570-964F05178A25}

                              SH

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X